The Right House in the Wrong Place

Posted By Steve Janes  

That quiet shift no one talks about after relocating to Melbourne.

You’ve just relocated to Melbourne from New York, a city where life spills onto the sidewalks, where convenience and connection are second nature, and where your neighbourhood is your lifestyle.

Now, you’re in a spacious townhouse in Murrumbeena. It ticks all the boxes from modern layout, space for your little one to play, a school in the neighbourhood that came highly recommended, and the comfort of being close to extended family. It makes sense on paper. But something still doesn’t feel quite right.

The house is lovely. The routine is in place. You’re doing your best to adjust and yet… a quiet discomfort lingers.

It’s something we hear more often than people expect. Because relocation isn’t just a change of address, it’s a complete rewiring of what “home” feels like. What seemed practical at the time, a school zone, a lease, a commute, slowly reveals what it lacks: the subtle but essential parts of life that make a place feel like home.

You miss the rhythm you were used to. The morning walk to your favourite café. The casual connection to community. The option to pop out for dinner without getting in a car. The hum of cultural art, diversity, and energy right at your doorstep. You’ve landed in Melbourne, but you haven’t truly settled.

🌿 And that’s where it gets real.
Because for many expats, particularly those used to fast-paced, connected cities like Hong Kong & New York, the disconnect isn’t about the house at all:

  • It’s about identity.
  • It’s about culture
  • It’s about how your environment shapes the way you feel.

When you’re juggling school runs, caring for family, and trying to build a new life. Lifestyle can quietly slip down the priority list. But over time, the cost of not feeling aligned starts to show.

And no one, not your relocation agent, not the property portals, warned you that your suburb might meet your needs, but not your soul.

💭 What if someone asked the deeper questions?

  • What parts of your past lifestyle do you want to keep?
  • Where do you want your child to grow up? not just geographically, but culturally?
  • What does “home” really mean to you, beyond price and practicality?

That’s where things begin to shift.

Recently, a family found themselves in exactly this position. They came to Melbourne through a relocation agent. The house was fine. The area was safe. The school was sorted. But after a few months, the mismatch between what they had and how they wanted to live became impossible to ignore. Their journey to realignment didn’t begin with a listing. It began with a conversation referred by one of our long-term tenants, someone who experienced firsthand that we don’t just manage property. We understand people.

At Property Shortlist, that’s the difference 💛

We don’t just match you with homes.
We notice what isn’t said in the brief.
We create space for clarity and help people realign their surroundings with their values.

Because the truth is, home isn’t a transaction.
It’s a feeling.
And if you’re feeling out of step, that doesn’t mean you made the wrong choice.
It just means it’s time to realign.

Still feeling like you haven’t quite found your place in Melbourne?
You’re not alone, and you don’t have to figure it out by yourself.
Let’s talk about what feels like home… and take it from there 🏡